Useragent parser comparison v4

We took 29543 different user agents and analyzed them with all providers below.
That way, it's possible to get a good overview of each provider

Detected by all providers

Provider Results Browser Engine Operating system Device brand Device model Device type Is mobile Is bot Parse time Actions
BrowscapPhp
6012
83.6%
Tot.24697
 
78.35%
Tot.23148
Unq.255
69.62%
Tot.20567
Unq.13
72.06%
Tot.21289
Unq.58
23.2%
Tot.6854
Unq.285
19.49%
Tot.5758
Unq.1945
78.29%
Tot.23128
Unq.9
70.49%
Tot.20824
 
 1549 0.03155 Details
DonatjUAParser
v0.5.0
95.23%
Tot.28133
 
95.23%
Tot.28133
Unq.4844
 0.00021 Details
NeutrinoApiCom
Cloud API
97.93%
Tot.28930
 
84.39%
Tot.24930
Unq.249
76.89%
Tot.22717
Unq.64
75.65%
Tot.22349
Unq.484
81.01%
Tot.23933
Unq.12970
94.66%
Tot.27966
Unq.6
77.17%
Tot.22797
 
 964 0.2429 Details
PiwikDeviceDetector
3.5.2
98.65%
Tot.29145
 
83.21%
Tot.24584
Unq.171
71.78%
Tot.21207
Unq.11
77.32%
Tot.22844
Unq.68
74.62%
Tot.22044
Unq.268
74.22%
Tot.21926
Unq.11174
85.79%
Tot.25345
Unq.11
84.49%
Tot.24962
 
 1234 0.00679 Details
SinergiBrowserDetector
6.0.0
82.42%
Tot.24348
 
76.86%
Tot.22706
Unq.31
73.41%
Tot.21687
Unq.15
2.06%
Tot.610
Unq.2
60.63%
Tot.17912
 
 1002 0.0007 Details
UAParser
v3.4.5
98.19%
Tot.29009
 
80.74%
Tot.23853
Unq.178
74.08%
Tot.21884
Unq.73
77.92%
Tot.23021
Unq.287
82.43%
Tot.24352
Unq.14775
 1233 0.00257 Details
UserAgentStringCom
Cloud API
76.79%
Tot.22685
 
75.51%
Tot.22308
Unq.121
66.72%
Tot.19710
Unq.45
 377 0.09751 Details
WhatIsMyBrowserCom
Cloud API
93.4%
Tot.27592
 
82.87%
Tot.24483
Unq.172
67.76%
Tot.20017
Unq.5
73.56%
Tot.21731
Unq.27
32.06%
Tot.9471
Unq.29
20.17%
Tot.5959
Unq.2660
 0.4308 Details
WhichBrowser
2.0.10
98.17%
Tot.29001
 
81.44%
Tot.24061
Unq.302
69.83%
Tot.20631
Unq.9
75.62%
Tot.22341
Unq.91
76.75%
Tot.22674
Unq.424
84.78%
Tot.25047
Unq.11870
94.11%
Tot.27803
Unq.21
84.8%
Tot.25053
 
 1084 0.00673 Details
Woothee
v1.2.0
78.91%
Tot.23313
 
67.6%
Tot.19972
Unq.30
73.38%
Tot.21680
Unq.5
 973 0.00026 Details
Wurfl
1.6.4
93.57%
Tot.27643
 
81.58%
Tot.24101
Unq.43
77.52%
Tot.22901
Unq.31
48.9%
Tot.14446
Unq.381
48.21%
Tot.14244
Unq.7254
93.07%
Tot.27495
Unq.7
83.53%
Tot.24678
 
 148 0.02624 Details

Detected by all providers

Browser names

Rendering engines

Operating systems

Device brands

Device models

Device types

Bot names

Bot types

Sources of the user agents

The user agents were extracted from the test suites of the following providers
Note The actual number of tested user agents can be higher in the test suite itself.
If a user agent is used in multiple test suites, the last one "wins" and overwrites the previous!
Provider Number of user agents
browscap/browscap4597
piwik/device-detector4161
ua-parser/uap-core16511
whichbrowser/parser4119
woothee/woothee-testset155

About this comparison

The primary goal of this project is simple
I wanted to know which user agent parser is the most accurate in each part - device detection, bot detection and so on...

The secondary goal is to provide a source for all user agent parsers to improve their detection based on this results.

You can also improve this further, by suggesting ideas at ThaDafinser/UserAgentParserComparison

The comparison is based on the abstraction by ThaDafinser/UserAgentParser
Comparison created 2016-02-19 07:52:32 | by ThaDafinser